The family of Jonathon Cote, who was kidnapped and murdered while working as a security contractor in Iraq 20 years ago this month, have kept his memory alive by doing charitable acts in Cote’s name.
Twenty years ago this month, a family in Amherst was jolted with terrifying news about a loved one – Jonathon M. Cote, a 23-year-old Army veteran who had taken on a dangerous job as a private security contractor in Iraq.

On Nov. 16, 2006, Cote and four co-workers were kidnapped by terrorists while they were escorting a convoy of 40 Italian Army trucks from Kuwait to an air base in Iraq.
Over the next 17 months, the news only got worse for Cote’s father, Francis Cote; brother, Christopher Cote; mother, Lori Silveri (Francis’ ex-wife) and other family members.
Five weeks after the kidnapping, terrorists released a video of Cote and his fellow captives asking Americans to pressure the U.S. government to leave Iraq. In March 2008, the severed fingers of Cote and four other captives were sent to American authorities in Iraq.
In April 2008, the bodies of Cote and his cohorts were recovered in shallow graves in Iraq. Cote had been brutally beaten and beheaded. Who killed them, and why? Those questions have never been answered. No individual or terrorist group has ever been held responsible for the brutality.
Francis Cote, a Marine Corps veteran and retired computer consultant, now 68 and still living in Amherst, struggles with his feelings about what happened to his son.
“I think about Jonathon every day, and I talk to him sometimes in my prayers,” Francis Cote told The Buffalo News last week. “Not knowing why this happened has been frustrating. At one point, I was determined to go over there and use my military skills to try to find out who did it. My wife talked me out of it, and it’s best that she did.”
“I try not to think about it too much, because it leads to depressing thoughts,” said Jonathon’s brother, Christopher Cote. “I try to focus on the good times we had. I have four little girls of my own, and I often tell them about Jon, what a great and fun uncle he would have been.”
No terrorist group ever asked for a ransom or claimed responsibility, said Joseph A. Niland, a former federal Drug Enforcement Administration agent who spent five years in Iraq investigating the kidnappings and murders.
“I worked with a team of FBI agents, people of very high character, and we tried very hard to find answers,” Niland said. “It’s frustrating to me that no one was legally held responsible. The Cotes are wonderful people and they deserve to find out.”
A possible link
Niland said he believes one man who was at least tangentially involved in Jonathon Cote’s death was killed on June 12.
Niland identified that man as Ali Musa Daqduq, a Hezbollah terrorist. According to multiple news reports, Daqduq was killed by Israeli forces in an air strike in southern Lebanon.
During the time period when Cote was abducted, Daqduq oversaw similar terrorist incidents in Iraq, and probably would have overseen the group that killed Cote and his colleagues, Niland said.
Last week, the U.S. State Department and the national FBI press office both acknowledged receiving information requests from a News reporter but did not provide any update on the Cote case.
Contractor deaths treated differently
“Anytime when we have American citizens who are captured and in harm’s way, we take those investigations very seriously,” an FBI spokeswoman told The News in 2008.
But Steve Fainaru, a Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist who wrote a book about private military contractors in 2008, said he believes the case of Cote and his slain colleagues would have received much more attention from the government if they were active duty soldiers.
In Fainaru’s opinion, America’s military depends on help from private contractors in the Middle East, but when things go wrong, the U.S. government quickly tries to distance itself from their activities.
Before Cote’s body was recovered, his family received regular investigation updates from the State Department and the FBI, but the family has received almost no information from either agency – except for updates informally provided by Niland – in about 19 years, Francis Cote said.
“We truly appreciate the efforts of Joe Niland and the agents who worked with him, but I don’t think our government really has the apparatus in place to conduct this kind of investigation,” Francis Cote said. “I don’t think our government did everything it could to find out who killed Jonathon and the men who died with him.”
Authorities identified the other men who were kidnapped and murdered with Cote as Paul Reuben, Joshua Munns, John Roy Young and Bert Nussbaumer. All worked for the Crescent Security Group. Nussbaumer was Austrian, and the other victims were Americans. The body of a sixth private contractor who worked for a different company, American Ronald Withrow, was found with the others.
Family keeps memory alive
His brother, Chris, remembers Jonathon as an energetic, fun-loving adventurer who enjoyed snowboarding, skydiving, motorcycling and other intense activities. He was also deeply devoted to his military service.
Jonathon graduated from Williamsville North High School in 2001. According to his family, he was preparing to attend Buffalo State College when an Army recruiter approached him with an offer to try out for the prestigious 82nd Airborne Division and get paid to jump out of airplanes. He eagerly enlisted at age 18.
When Jonathon joined the Army, America was in a time of relative peace. But a few months later, the nation was rocked by the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11. The Army sent Cote on tours of duty in Afghanistan at age 20 and Iraq at age 21. He told his family he spent most of his time guarding military bases and supply convoys.
Jonathon ended his service in 2004 and enrolled in the University of Florida, where he studied accounting. He became bored with accounting, and in 2006, he accepted an offer from an Army colleague to return to the Mideast as a private contractor for a Kuwait-based company, Crescent Security Group.
His family said Crescent offered Cote $7,000 a month – far more money than he’d ever made – and he became one of thousands of American military veterans to take security jobs in the Middle East.
Private security contractors like Cote have worked closely with military personnel from the U.S. and other countries for decades, according to a 2021 study by the Brown University Cost of War Project.
At least 8,189 private contractors were killed in the Middle East in the two decades after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, the Brown study concluded.
‘Do good things’
The past 20 years have been painful for the Cote family, but Francis Cote said one thing has helped – a series of fundraising events, held in Jonathon’s honor, that have raised more than $100,000 for charities.
The fundraisers, including several motorcycle runs and several “workout fundraisers” at a Getzville gym, were run by Chris Cote; Jonathon’s stepsister, Samantha Dunford; Francis’ second wife, Nancy Cote; and other volunteers.
The family also started a nonprofit foundation in Jonathon’s name, which will support scholarships and donations to charities, Francis Cote said.
He said he also does extensive volunteer work at his church, Holy Cross Lutheran in Clarence.
“A grief counselor told me after Jon died, ‘Keep yourself active, and do good things in your son’s name,’” Francis Cote said. “My faith, my family and doing those things, have gotten me through the past 20 years.”

